Home / Advisory / Software Selection

Software Selection Advisory

Independent advice for enterprise software decisions.

A new warehouse, transportation or supply chain system shapes how you operate for a decade. We run a structured, independent selection so you choose the software and the implementation partner that fit your business, at a price negotiated with full information.

A typical selectionWMS / TMS
Key qualification criteriaWhat sets your operation apart
8–12
Market scanCandidate vendors and integrators
5–7
Scripted demosYour scenarios, your data
2–3
Best and final offerDue diligence and negotiation
BAFO
Vendor selectedSoftware plus implementation partner
1

Systems we evaluate

Off-the-shelf software, chosen to fit

Commercial software now covers most of what a supply chain needs. Where you need something unique, it can usually be built as an extension. The hard part is picking the right foundation.

  • Warehouse management (WMS)WMS
  • Transportation management (TMS)TMS
  • Supply chain management suitesSCM
  • Software as a serviceSaaS
  • Yard management (YMS)YMS
  • Data analytics platformsBI

Why it's hard

Challenges in software selection

Doing it right takes process assessment, a business case, clear requirements, vendor screening and well-run demonstrations. Few teams have the time and tools to do all of it alongside their day jobs.

Fit

Good on the surface

Some systems demo well but fit poorly, or leave no room to grow. Vendor viability, reliability and ease of implementation matter as much as features.

Roadmaps

Years of acquisitions

After many vendor mergers, it is not always clear which products a vendor will keep investing in. We look past the brochure to the roadmap.

Cloud

Is it really SaaS?

Some "cloud" offerings are true multi-tenant SaaS; others are the old product hosted in a data center. We explain the difference and when it matters.

Process

From strategy and roadmap to vendor selection

Two phases, sized to the decision in front of you. Smaller selections use only the steps they need.

Phase 1

Strategy and roadmap

  1. 01

    Current state assessment

    Where you are today

    • Stakeholder interviews
    • Process health survey
    • Process framing
    • Applications review
  2. 02

    Scenario analysis

    Your realistic options

    • Future-state vision
    • Alternative scenarios
  3. 03

    Financial modeling

    What each option costs

    • IT spending benchmark
    • Budgetary business case
  4. 04

    Market scan

    5–7 candidate vendors

    • Qualification criteria (8–12)
    • RFI and vendor and SI analysis
  5. 05

    Strategy and roadmap

    One plan to act on

    • Strategic story
    • Strategic initiatives
    • Change management plan
Phase 2

Selection and transaction

  1. 01

    Request for proposal

    Formal, contract-ready

    • Baseline requirements
    • RFP and contract package
  2. 02

    Software demonstrations

    2–3 finalists

    • Scripted demo scenarios
    • Demonstrations
  3. 03

    Evaluate vendors and SIs

    Facts, not impressions

    • Response analysis
    • Mutual due diligence
  4. 04

    BAFO and negotiation

    Best terms, protected

    • Best and final offer
    • Contract negotiation
Generally includedOptional, sized to your project

Our differentiators

What we do differently

Surveys, not just interviews

We add short online surveys to stakeholder interviews, so we hear from far more of the people who will use the system and find the needs others miss.

Process framing

Instead of months of process mapping, we frame your key processes against better practices and define what the new system must support.

Focus on differentiators

We concentrate on what makes your operation different and what truly separates the vendors, and use that to drive the market scan.

Alternatives first

Before going to market, we test whether to replace, upgrade or extend, and whether a suite or best-of-breed approach fits better.

A short list, quickly

Formal criteria and a three-step qualification funnel get you to the right finalists without weeks of vendor sales calls.

The integrator matters

Many projects fail on implementation, not software. We weigh the implementation partner as heavily as the product.

Absolute independence. We do not sell software or partner with technology vendors for implementation services. We sit on your side of the table only. And our work does not have to end at signing: we can stay on for implementation project management, governance and change management.

Questions

Common questions

How long does a selection take?

It depends on scope and on how many sites and stakeholders are involved. We agree on a timeline at the start and size the process to the decision.

Do you only help with the selection?

No. We can continue through implementation with project management, governance and organizational change management.

How do you stay independent?

We don't sell software and don't partner with vendors for implementation work. Our recommendation is based only on your requirements.

We already have a vendor in mind. Can you still help?

Yes. We can test that choice against the market, run scripted demonstrations and support the negotiation, so you sign with confidence and better terms.

Contact

Planning a WMS, TMS or SCM decision?

Tell us where you are in the process, and we'll set up a time to talk it through.